One-Vote Win Sparks Legal Firestorm: TVK MLA Heads to SC
A single vote has triggered a constitutional showdown in Tamil Nadu, with TVK's R. Srinivasan Sethupathy racing to the Supreme Court against a Madras High Court gag on his floor test involvement....
A single vote has triggered a constitutional showdown in Tamil Nadu, with TVK's R. Srinivasan Sethupathy racing to the Supreme Court against a Madras High Court gag on his floor test involvement. Elected from Tirupattur by the slimmest margin, Sethupathy contests the order amid allegations of ballot mishandling. Defeated DMK leader KR Periakaruppan's petition spotlighted chaos: a postal ballot for Tirupattur (seat 185, Shivaganga) was erroneously dispatched to seat 50 (Tirupattur, Vellore vicinity) and discarded. Sethupathy edged out with 83,365 votes to 83,364. Justices L. Victoria Gauri and N. Senthilkumar termed it a peculiar electoral anomaly, far beyond standard disputes— a systemic lapse in process integrity. They flagged an 18-vote EVM inconsistency, mandating record preservation for scrutiny. The court underscored: in nail-biter elections, each vote is kingmaker. Yet, it affirmed no immediate election reversal or victory grant to Periakaruppan. The Election Commission pushed back, advocating exclusive use of 1951 Act election petitions. Urgently mentioned by Abhishek Manu Singhvi before CJI DY Chandrachud, the SC slotted it for Wednesday. This high-stakes clash tests judicial oversight of elections. Beyond the wires, it spotlights urgent reforms needed in postal voting logistics and real-time discrepancy checks, ensuring no vote is lost in transit. Tamil Nadu watches as the apex court weighs in on this democratic tightrope.