Skip to content

Trump Govt Proposal May Tighten H-1B, L-1 Extensions

By News Analysis India · · 3 min read

Washington, November 2: The Trump administration has proposed an immigration change that could make it harder for Indian professionals to extend their US work visas. If adopted, the rule would stop immigration officers from being bound by previous approvals when reviewing extension requests for H-1B and L-1 visa holders.

Indian-origin professionals form the largest group in this area. About 79 per cent of approvals for continued employment under the H-1B visa are granted to people of Indian origin.

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has released a proposal called 'Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility'. Public comments can be submitted until November 13. The proposal was published in the Federal Register on October 14. Responses must be filed only through the official government website Regulations.gov.

The move targets the existing rule 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5). Under that provision, when a visa has already been approved for a worker and employer, officers usually have to respect the earlier decision unless there has been a significant change in circumstances, a material error, or new adverse information.

The proposed change would apply beyond H-1B and L-1. Categories including O-1, TN, E and P visas would also be impacted. In practical terms, a worker who has already received a visa could still see their application re-examined from the beginning when seeking an extension.

USCIS data shows that nearly 3.99 lakh H-1B visa applications were approved in fiscal year 2024. About 71 per cent of these beneficiaries were born in India. Within the continuing employment category, which also includes extension applications, roughly 2.03 lakh of about 2.58 lakh approvals, around 79 per cent, went to Indian-origin professionals.

According to DHS, H-1B petitions make up more than 75 per cent of all Form I-129 filings received by USCIS. The department expects around 2.08 lakh applications to be affected each year.

DHS also warned that the change could increase the rate of Requests for Evidence (RFEs), notices asking applicants for more documents or explanations, by nearly three percentage points. This would mean around 6,000 extra notices annually. Applications that receive such requests take an average of 64 additional days to be decided, based on the last four fiscal years. The department estimates the added cost for applicants and employers at roughly 1.34 lakh dollars per year.

The department's rationale is that the current system puts the onus on immigration officers to justify why a decision differs from a prior one. DHS says the proposed rule would let officers weigh each case on its own facts.

DHS also pointed to worksite inspection findings. It said that between fiscal years 2022 and 2025, about 22 per cent of inspected H-1B extension worksites were found to have both violations and fraud. For fiscal years 2018 to 2020, the figure was about 17 per cent. The department noted that these periods include both times when the prior approval policy was in place and times when it was not.

Despite the change, DHS says officers will not disregard earlier approvals entirely. They may still consider past decisions, but will not be required to follow them.

The department has admitted that the proposal could disrupt the plans of workers and companies that built their careers and personal lives around prior visa approvals and their legal stay in the US.

The prior approval policy has changed several times. It was first introduced in 2004, ended in 2017 during Trump's first term, restored in 2021, and formally written into immigration regulations in 2024.