Polish President Cuts Foreign Trip Short Amid Court Crisis
Warsaw, October 31: Polish President Karol Nawrocki has cut short a foreign visit and returned to Poland as a political and legal crisis deepens over the suspension of the head of the country's Constitutional Tribunal.
The move followed the issuing of an order suspending the tribunal's president and his deputy. The decision sparked street protests that turned violent on Friday night, with police clashing with demonstrators near the court's headquarters.
Opposition leaders have labeled the development a "coup," while Prime Minister Donald Tusk has argued that the government is acting to restore legal order.
A Dispute Over Judges and Authority
The latest escalation builds on a long-running conflict over who controls the Constitutional Tribunal. Five judges were elected by parliament, but tribunal president Bogdan Święczkowski blocked them from taking part in cases. Nawrocki declined to administer their oaths of office.
The five judges later took their oaths during a ceremony in parliament. However, Nawrocki and Święczkowski do not consider that swearing-in valid.
The tribunal is responsible for reviewing whether Polish laws conform to the constitution. Over the years, it has become a focal point of legal and political controversy. Critics of the previous Law and Justice (PiS) government accused it of stacking the court with loyal judges, a charge that has shaped the debate ever since.
The Suspension and Its Legal Basis
On Friday, Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, one of the five judges, suspended Święczkowski and his deputy, Bartłomiej Sochański, from their duties for a month. She based her decision on her seniority as a judge and on Article 130 of the law governing common courts.
That provision allows a judge to be temporarily removed from duties if caught committing a deliberate offense or if their conduct undermines the dignity of the court. It also applies when immediate removal is necessary to protect the essential interests of the judiciary.
Korwin-Piotrowska, now acting as head of the tribunal, described the steps as constitutionally necessary. She accused Święczkowski of irregularities, including blocking meetings of the court's general assembly.
The Tribunal's Response
The tribunal said on its social media profile that its website had been illegally taken over and that Święczkowski remained its president. A spokesperson insisted that, whatever others believed, the court's leadership still rested with Święczkowski. The spokesperson also said the police intervention had been pre-planned.
Nawrocki announced his return on social media after police entered the tribunal building in Warsaw. Some demonstrators outside had begun throwing objects at officers.
Wider Stakes for Poland and the EU
The standoff reflects a broader struggle over the rule of law that has strained Poland's ties with the European Union. Brussels froze billions of euros in funding over concerns about democratic decline and the politicization of the judiciary.
Tusk's centrist coalition came to power at the end of 2023 after campaigning on a promise to restore judicial independence. He has repeatedly questioned the legitimacy of the tribunal and ignored some of its rulings.
Writing on social media on Friday evening, Tusk said: "Restoring the rule of law is our duty. After years of chaos during the PiS era, this is a difficult and sometimes painful process that requires decisive steps. There is no other option."