Skip to content

No Need for Pakistan to Lecture India on Religious Freedom

By News Analysis India · · 2 min read

India has sharply rejected a United Nations report on religious freedom, describing it as one-sided and calling for a more balanced approach in international discussions on human rights. The criticism was delivered at the UN General Assembly's Third Committee, which focuses on humanitarian and social issues.

Speaking on Thursday, Bhavika Mangalanandan, First Secretary at India's Mission to the United Nations, responded to a report submitted by UN Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief Nazila Ghanea. The report examined the right to funeral and burial in exceptional circumstances.

According to the report, some people killed in security operations in Kashmir were not returned to their families and were buried in remote locations. It also stated that authorities imposed restrictions on funerals of some individuals who died during protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act, citing law and order concerns.

Mangalanandan said the subject of the report should not be used to extract political advantage from people's pain and loss. She further argued that it was surprising that the rights of terrorists were defended vigorously, while similar concern was rarely shown for victims of terrorism.

She stressed that terrorism is an attack on the most basic human right, the right to life. Terrorists, she said, not only kill innocent people but also weaken the morale and mindset of entire nations.

India also objected to the way the report addressed burial practices during the Covid-19 pandemic. According to New Delhi, the report discussed alleged discrimination and wrongful practices only in the context of the Global South, without referring to similar incidents in developed nations.

“Reading the report, one would think that all mistakes and discrimination during Covid-19 happened only in the Global South,” Mangalanandan said. She questioned what the report gained by leaving out comparable tragedies in developed countries.

As an example, she pointed to New York City, where thousands of people who died during the pandemic were buried in mass graves on a separate island away from the city. She said the report made no mention of such events.

Responding to remarks made by Pakistan during the meeting, Mangalanandan described the criticism as highly ironic. She said a country that refused to accept the bodies of its own soldiers who died in the 1999 Kargil conflict was now speaking enthusiastically about religion, religious freedom and burial rights.

She pointed out that the Indian Army had buried several Pakistani soldiers with military honours and in line with Islamic customs.

Mangalanandan urged Pakistan to focus on the Kashmir region that it occupies illegally, rather than continually commenting on India. She also said that minority rights in Pakistan have been steadily eroding and that cases of abuse against minorities are regularly reported.

She concluded that a country unable to guarantee the security of its own minorities has no right to preach to India.