Skip to content

Pakistan's Crackdown in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Raises Security Alarm

By News Analysis India · · 2 min read

Pakistan's security establishment is facing growing criticism over its approach to Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, with a new report warning that the province could slip further into instability. The report links the approach to the broader 'hard-state' doctrine associated with Army Chief Asim Munir, which assumes that resistance is mainly the result of insufficient force.

Khyber Pakhtunkhwa is home to more than 40 million people, has powerful political organisations, and is witnessing an armed insurgency across its territory. Its border with Afghanistan adds to the complexity of the security picture. The report says these conditions make the province the most demanding test of this strategy.

Development of the province's critical minerals is also unlikely to proceed smoothly, the report notes. A full geological survey of the mineral deposits has yet to be carried out, processing capacity is limited, and security conditions are steadily worsening.

The report suggests that the deteriorating situation could lead the military establishment to demand larger allocations from the central government for security operations. It may also seek to strengthen its grip on the province's mineral resources and take steps toward selling them to Western purchasers.

The report questions the motives behind the recent political changes. Many observers are asking whether Islamabad dismissed the elected provincial government to secure control over the province's mineral wealth. According to the report, the known facts point to an even more significant development. A constitutional arrangement introduced in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa on October 11, 2026, eliminated a barrier that had prevented federal control over the province's minerals for at least 18 months.

The federal government, with the support of the military establishment, invoked Articles 232 and 234 of the Constitution to impose emergency powers and governor's rule. Federal law will now take precedence wherever it conflicts with provincial law. Chief Minister Sohail Afridi has been detained under preventive custody.

The report recalls that minerals fall under provincial jurisdiction according to the 18th Constitutional Amendment. However, there is currently no provincial assembly capable of exercising that power. Against this backdrop, the mistrust spreading among Pashtun political groups reflects a logical reaction to events rather than a mere conspiracy theory.

The report cautions that the security costs of this decision in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa may far outweigh any income the state could gain. Violence has already intensified. In the first half of 2026, the number of police personnel killed rose to 122, up from 63 a year earlier. Between July and September 2026, violence-related deaths totalled 556, compared with 475 in the previous quarter.

Islamabad has cited the worsening security environment as the reason for imposing emergency rule in the province. The report, however, contends that removing the only elected government that enjoys legitimacy among Pashtuns, detaining its chief minister, and opening the province's resources to federal and foreign control will not halt the violence.

The report warns that such steps would hand militant groups a powerful argument for their cause. It adds that the province could face a situation similar to Balochistan, where administrative governance has become exceptionally difficult.