Skip to content

Khanna vs Tandon: Immigration, Green Cards and Wealth Tax Debate

By News Analysis India · · 2 min read

Two Indian-American candidates vying for California's 17th Congressional District seat went head-to-head in a heated online debate on Wednesday, with immigration, green card reform and taxation on the wealthiest Americans dominating the discussion.

Democrat Ro Khanna and Republican Ritesh Tandon faced off in a roughly 50-minute exchange that was broadcast live on Tandon's campaign YouTube channel, US time, on Wednesday evening. Khanna remained for the full session, answered every question and gave a closing statement.

The tone began on a cordial note. Khanna praised Tandon's civility over recent years, saying that the ability to debate ideas with people one often disagrees with is vital to democracy.

Immigration enforcement quickly emerged as the sharpest point of difference. Khanna stated plainly that he would abolish Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), calling the agency unaccountable. In its place, he proposed a body modelled on the former Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS), placed within the Justice Department, guided by humanitarian principles and focused on tackling sex trafficking and serious criminal activity.

He also backed clearer routes to permanent residency for international students, entrepreneurs and those who found companies in the United States.

Tandon framed his position through personal history. Having moved from India at 28, he said he had complied with every rule and waited patiently. He warned that more than 1.2 million people are caught in the backlog of pending green card applications. Taking aim at his opponent's record, he said Khanna had served in Congress for about a decade, yet the waiting list had only expanded.

Tandon's proposals include scrapping the per-country limit on green card issuance, recycling unused green cards, and cracking down on H-1B visa abuse. He also supports mandatory voter ID and wants illegal border crossings treated as a serious offence.

The per-country cap remains a long-standing grievance among Indian professionals, who endure the longest waits among employment-based green card applicants.

The debate also turned to economic policy. Khanna defended his plan for a five percent levy on billionaire wealth, asking why the economy appeared to serve only a small number of billionaires. He called for a new social contract that puts working and middle-class Americans first.

Tandon countered that the tax would target the value of assets on paper instead of actual income. He further argued that businesses and residents are leaving California.

Khanna rejected that view, insisting the AI boom is concentrated in Silicon Valley rather than emerging hubs such as Austin or Miami.

Tandon also criticised Khanna for steering the Democratic Party leftward, warning that democratic socialist politics could push the country toward outcomes similar to Venezuela. He highlighted Khanna's endorsement of a democratic socialist candidate for New York City mayor.