Why joining the Makkah joint defence treaty could jeopardise Bangladesh's interests
Dhaka – As Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and Turkey formalise the Makkah Joint Defence Treaty, speculation has arisen about Bangladesh’s possible involvement. A recent investigative piece warns that becoming a signatory might entangle the country in commitments that do not serve its strategic or economic goals.
The article emphasizes that before any combat engagement, Bangladesh must contemplate the decision repeatedly, ensuring it does not surrender its independent security agenda to external actors. The piece stresses the need for prudence to avoid falling into a “dangerous snare”.
When a nation joins a defence bloc, it does more than affix a name to a paper; it often cedes control over future policy choices. The initial promise of solidarity and mutual defence can mask complex dilemmas concerning sovereignty, fiscal strain and diplomatic balance.
Given its Muslim‑majority identity, Bangladesh might view collaboration with Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Pakistan as natural. Yet the report cautions that alliances should be based on hard geopolitical calculations rather than shared faith, taking into account geography, economic resilience, military capability and overarching national interest.
Bangladesh currently experiences no imminent external threat. In contrast, its prospective allies are preoccupied with distinct security concerns – the Iran‑Saudi competition, the long‑standing India‑Pakistan standoff, and Turkey’s strategic focus on Israel.
A thought experiment presented in the report asks whether Pakistan would battle Myanmar on Bangladesh’s behalf, if such a conflict erupted, or whether Saudi troops would be dispatched to defend Dhaka, or if Turkey would send assistance via the Bay of Bengal. The answers underscore the practical limits of treaty obligations.
The history of alliances such as CENTO, SEATO and NATO illustrates that not all members receive equal protection; disparities in military strength, economic responsibilities and geopolitical leverage often persist.
While Bangladesh has ongoing disagreements with India over border demarcation, water allocation, extradition protocols and trade issues, the analysis warns that adopting an outright anti‑India position without a cohesive strategy could trigger economic retaliation outweighing any military advantage.
Bangladesh’s dependence on fuel, electricity, gas, food supplies and trade corridors – many of which intersect with Indian infrastructure – means that seeking the safety net of a distant coalition may ultimately jeopardise its own security and prosperity.