India Calls for Reform as UNSC Debates Veto Powers
New York, October 27: India has voiced sharp concerns over the functioning of veto powers at the United Nations Security Council, highlighting what it describes as a 'de facto veto' that is influencing reform talks and Council decisions.
India's Permanent Representative to the UN, P. Harish, made the remarks on Monday during a General Assembly discussion on the veto rights held by the five permanent members, known as P5. He argued that the veto is meant to instil a sense of duty, not personal entitlement.
The debate touched on the Intergovernmental Negotiations (IGN) on Security Council reform. Harish said that the veto question had become a major obstacle in the process, as some countries had resorted to indirect vetoes that have brought negotiations to a standstill.
"Within the IGN process too, the plea for 'consensus' is being employed as a hidden, de facto veto," he stated.
India maintains that the veto privilege must not be used to serve narrow political objectives.
The Uniting for Consensus group, a small bloc of countries led by Italy with Pakistan among its members, has used procedural tactics to prevent the IGN from adopting a draft for negotiations, Harish said.
He emphasised that the 2008 General Assembly decision, the foundational guideline for the IGN, clearly states that the core principle is 'maximum political acceptance' rather than 'consensus'.
After 17 rounds of talks, Harish said, there was "no outcome to show" for the effort. He blamed a 'practical veto' that, in his view, finds no basis in the resolution that established the IGN.
He urged that negotiations on a draft text begin soon, with clear timelines and objectives, to kick-start broader reforms.
Harish also drew attention to secret vetoes that have no recognition in the UN Charter yet are allowed to be exercised by non-permanent members on some significant issues.
"The veto is not limited to what is exercised openly. There is also a de facto veto, available to every member of the Security Council, whether elected or not. They can use it against presidential statements, press statements and sanctions committee decisions," he said.
This is possible because of an "unwritten rule of consensus" under which a single member can stall any proposal, often without offering any justification. Harish cited several occasions on which China had blocked attempts in closed sanctions committee sessions to impose measures on Pakistan-based terrorists, among them Lashkar-e-Taiba's Zakir-ur-Rehman Lakhvi and Shahid Mahmood, and Jaish-e-Mohammed's Sajid Mir and Masood Azhar.
Calling for sweeping reform, Harish said questions about the Council's credibility, legitimacy and effectiveness will not be resolved merely by managing the veto. Reform must also involve enlarging the Council and admitting new permanent members.
"The answers to these questions will come from a Council that is fully suited to its purpose, whose composition mirrors today's realities and not the results of a war fought eight decades ago," he said.
Harish stated that India has taken a 'principle-based stance', holding that any country that becomes a permanent member through reform must also receive veto power.
"We reaffirm that for as long as the veto exists, all permanent members of a reformed Council must enjoy this right," he said, adding that this is what fairness and justice require.
He rejected the idea of creating new 'second-class' tiers of membership, such as long-term members or permanent members without veto rights. Such a step, he cautioned, would make an already difficult reform discussion even more complex and widen the very inequality that needs to be addressed.
Harish was also sceptical of the proposal that states using the veto in the Council should explain their decisions before the General Assembly. Although the measure was intended to promote change and accountability, the extensive use of the veto since its adoption, he said, has told a "completely opposite story".