Skip to content

Human rights groups label proposed law as repressive

By News Analysis India · · 1 min read

Islamabad, July 10 — A coalition of human‑rights lawyers, journalists and civil‑society workers demanded the immediate repeal of Punjab’s draft Habitual Offenders Bill, calling it a "repressive" and "backward" piece of legislation.

During a HRCP‑facilitated discussion, attorney Asad Jamal explained that the bill empowers the state to dismiss civil freedoms by using ambiguous language such as “habitual criminal” and “anti‑social conduct”. He singled out section 5, which would let the provincial government commission an intelligence committee to brand any person a habitual offender and open criminal proceedings without any external checks.

Educationist Adnan Sattar warned that the measure pushes "authoritarian legitimacy" to its peak, urging NGOs to launch coordinated, on‑ground campaigns. HRCP Punjab deputy chair Raja Ashraf observed the shrinking room for open parliamentary debate.

Lawyer Ali Javed Darogha described the draft as a contemporary echo of colonial‑era statutes, arguing that true reform requires devolving power and ensuring government accountability.

PTI MP Sheikh Imtiaz claimed the bill infringes at least fourteen constitutional provisions, including the guarantee of a fair hearing and freedom of movement, noting that lawmakers are often denied access to the bill’s text before deliberations.

HRCP also highlighted its recent concerns over a series of alleged extrajudicial police encounters in Punjab, citing official data of 808 such incidents that have resulted in 1,100 suspect deaths. The commission warned that the Crime Control Department repeatedly employs deadly force under the pretext of crime control.

The death of a nine‑year‑old child, cited by HRCP, underscores a worrying trend of lethal force being used outside judicial scrutiny. The commission demanded a full judicial investigation, stressing that internal departmental reviews are insufficient without independent oversight.