Skip to content

Exploring Consciousness with Professor Steve Fleming

By News Analysis India · · 2 min read

University College London’s Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience welcomed a cross‑disciplinary talk on July 9, featuring Professor Steve Fleming, a leading figure in the study of consciousness and metacognition. Co‑hosted with philosopher Acharya Prashant, the conversation examined how the brain creates a model of itself and what that implies for the sense of self.

Fleming began by describing the brain as a self‑monitoring engine. While it constructs representations of the external world, it also builds an internal picture of its own operations. This internal picture, he noted, is not perfectly accurate; confidence judgments often overshoot or undershoot actual performance. He cited his award‑winning research that maps these confidence errors to activity in the prefrontal cortex, arguing that the same neural circuitry that generates thoughts also generates the feeling of knowing.

The philosopher responded with a metaphor of a driver‑less vehicle. In his view, the engine (thought) runs without a driver (self), and the dashboard (confidence) merely reads the speed. The true speed, measured by an external radar, is the ground truth that the system can never fully access. The gap between dashboard and radar illustrates the persistent bias in self‑evaluation, while their joint operation signals metacognitive sensitivity.

The dialogue turned to the role of ego. Prashant described ego as a computational error – a false claim of ownership that the brain invents to maintain a narrative. He emphasized that suffering originates not in the body but in this narrative loop. Fleming linked this to the “user illusion” concept advanced by philosopher Daniel Dennett, suggesting that the brain’s story‑making capacities generate the illusion of a central controller.

Audience questions covered topics ranging from the heart’s influence on perception to the possibility of machine consciousness. Fleming argued that the heart’s rhythmic signals modulate attentional filters, while the hard problem of consciousness may be better framed as a moral question about how we treat subjective experience. The session concluded with both speakers urging listeners to seek an external, trustworthy mirror – a friend, a book, or a teacher – to test the validity of their internal narratives.