Washington witnessed a poignant protest at the State of the Union when Rep. John Garamendi (D-CA) arrived with an empty guest seat reserved for deported Indian American Harjeet Kaur, 73. The gesture spotlighted the elderly woman’s harrowing deportation experience, criticizing stringent immigration enforcement.
Kaur had called California home since the early 1990s, enduring a denied asylum bid in 2012 but steadfastly attending mandatory check-ins for 13+ years. Garamendi dedicated the seat in her name: ‘This is for 73-year-old grandmother Harjeet Kaur, deported ruthlessly at midnight. It represents everyone caged, silenced, or killed by Trump’s immigration crackdown—the stark human price.’
Her nightmare unfolded September 8, 2025: seized at a routine San Francisco appointment, held in Bakersfield, then Mesa Verde. At 2 a.m. on September 19, handcuffed and unannounced to kin or counsel, she was rushed to LA, Georgia, and shoved onto an India-bound charter. Missing for over a day, her family’s farewell dreams shattered.
‘No criminal here—just a compliant grandma,’ Garamendi noted, slamming Trump’s ‘criminals first’ rhetoric amid widespread family devastation. Detention details are grim: floor sleeping sans furniture, shackles in transit, no veggie food for her beliefs, scarce hygiene, med delays for post-knee surgery, thyroid, migraines. No doctor visits; once, ice instead of dinner after starving all day; water rationed.
India now holds Kaur, health frail, isolated from US family aid. This saga revives immigration wars, with India among nations hit hard by US actions. Garamendi’s empty chair isn’t mere symbolism—it’s a demand for policy reckoning, urging America to weigh enforcement’s toll on innocents like Kaur. In polarized times, it bridges divides, humanizing statistics into stories of resilience and loss.