Skip to content

Democrats Demand Withdrawal of Census Rule Excluding Noncitizens

By News Analysis India · · 3 min read

Washington, October 31: Opposition to a proposed census rule has grown sharply in Washington. A group of more than 150 Democratic House members, among them five Indian-American legislators, has asked the Trump administration to withdraw a plan that would leave certain non-American citizens out of the population counts that determine how many congressional seats each state receives.

The public comment letter was signed by Pramila Jayapal, Ro Khanna, Raja Krishnamoorthi, Suhas Subramanyam and Shri Thanedar. The Congressional Asian Pacific American Caucus made the signatures public.

The effort was led by Robert Garcia, a senior Democrat on the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform. He was joined by the chairs of the Asian Pacific American, Hispanic, Black and Equality caucuses.

Garcia made clear the fight would continue beyond the comment period. "We will oppose this rule in Congress and in the courts," he said.

At the heart of the dispute is the 14th Amendment, which bases representation in each state on its total population. The lawmakers contend that the proposal runs against that constitutional principle. They also argue that limiting demographic questions would undermine protections needed for voting rights and civil rights.

Grace Meng, who chairs the Asian Pacific American Caucus, said the changes could weaken political representation for minority communities and limit access to resources they rely on. She also warned that the loss of reliable data would make it harder to identify disparities across communities.

The Census Bureau's proposal would keep green card holders in the population figures used for dividing congressional seats. Undocumented immigrants and non-citizens with legal status below permanent residency would be excluded. That group includes people living in the country on temporary visas.

The plan would also remove questions about race, ethnicity and sexual orientation from the census questionnaire. Those limits would not extend to the American Community Survey or other surveys that do not seek to count the entire population.

According to the Census Bureau, permanent residence and loyalty to the country should guide decisions about who is counted for congressional representation. The agency is weighing the use of administrative records to establish a person's legal status and has asked the public whether a legal status question should be added to the census form.

Illinois Republican Congresswoman Mary Miller issued a separate letter on Friday backing the proposal. She went further, calling for all non-American citizens, including green card holders, to be removed from the population used for allocating House seats.

Her group also urged limits on demographic questions in the American Community Survey, an extension beyond the Census Bureau's current plan. Miller's position is that representation should rest solely on American citizens.

The National Conference of State Legislatures asked for 60 more days to gather public feedback and consult with states. In its Friday comment, the group said census figures are central to drawing district boundaries and that survey estimates and administrative records are not an adequate substitute for the full census count.

It cautioned that changing data collection without consulting states could make it difficult to comply with redistricting laws. The American Community Survey typically offers data for broad geographic areas, not individual census blocks. States might therefore need to spend more money to obtain the smaller-area data required to draw accurate electoral maps.

The Census Bureau released the proposal on September 10. A notice issued on October 5 pushed back the deadline for public comments from October 13 to November 2.

The census takes place every 10 years in the United States. Its results determine how the 435 House seats are split among the 50 states according to population.