Skip to content

Balendra Shah Govt Faces Judiciary Fury Over CJ Appointment

Nepal's political landscape is fracturing along executive-judicial lines following the controversial recommendation of Justice Manoj Sharma as Chief Justice. Ranking fourth in Supreme Court...

By News Analysis India · · Updated · 1 min read

Nepal's political landscape is fracturing along executive-judicial lines following the controversial recommendation of Justice Manoj Sharma as Chief Justice. Ranking fourth in Supreme Court seniority, Sharma's nod by PM Balendra Shah's Constitutional Council on May 7 has dismantled a revered convention spanning decades. The fallout intensified when Acting Chief Justice Sapna Pradhan Malla, the senior-most judge, lashed out post-Law Day events. "This seeks to make the judiciary bow to executive whims," she asserted, decrying the seniority snub as a blatant power grab. Parliamentary dissenters, including key opposition figures, registered formal disagreements, advocating for precedent. Trailblazing ex-PM and CJI Sushila Karki decried the slight against women, positioning Malla as the epitome of judicial prowess—a view shared amid national discourse. Pro-government arguments hinge on Sharma's prolific output in judgments, outpacing seniors. Yet Malla challenged the opaque evaluation, insisting competence demands holistic scrutiny beyond volume. Expert Bipin Adhikari critiqued the metric, prioritizing precedent-setting depth over quantity. Historically, parliamentary hearings weeded out candidates on complaints, but this selection bypasses seniors outright. Constitutional provisions permit such choices, yet the shift alarms observers fearing favoritism and weakened oversight of the executive. Malla's impassioned address to peers emphasized courage against impeachment fears or majority pressures, safeguarding impartiality. As Nepal grapples with this institutional showdown, the presidency's role looms large, with implications for democratic integrity.