Skip to content

Arming Afghan Groups Could Backfire on Pakistan, Report Warns

By News Analysis India · · 2 min read

A new report suggests that Pakistan is turning to an old and dangerous tactic in its confrontation with Afghanistan's Taliban government. Reports indicate that Islamabad is backing Afghan armed groups by recruiting and arming them to fight militant organisations hostile to Pakistan. Observers say the move could create serious problems for Pakistan in the long run.

Zalmay Khalilzad, who once served as the United States' special envoy for Afghanistan, has raised alarm over the reported developments. Referring to news accounts that Pakistan's army has started supplying weapons to Afghans to counter terrorist groups targeting Islamabad, he said that relations between Kabul and Islamabad could worsen under present circumstances.

Pakistan's Ministry of Information has dismissed these allegations as baseless and misleading. Still, analysts say the reported step fits a pattern in the thinking of Pakistan's security establishment that has persisted for years.

For almost forty years, the report says, Islamabad saw the Afghan Taliban as a strategic asset. Pakistan's aims were to limit India's growing presence in Afghanistan and to secure a Kabul government that would align with its interests. Today, however, the relationship has deteriorated. Pakistan and the Afghan Taliban are locked in a low-intensity border conflict linked to the TTP.

Islamabad has repeatedly accused the Afghan Taliban of giving refuge to TTP fighters. Pakistan has pressed Kabul to take action, but the results have fallen short of its expectations. According to the report, Islamabad's disappointment with Kabul's unwillingness to restrain its ideological partners is pushing it back toward a historical approach of using one proxy to counter another.

Such a strategy, the report stresses, carries considerable risk. Pakistan has learned from experience that militant groups used for its foreign interests have often turned against the country. Organisations that received arms and support to fight abroad later attacked targets inside Pakistan.

According to the report, arming newer Afghan groups to weaken the TTP could give rise to unmanaged local militias. Such forces could intensify violence in a border region that is already fragile. The report also highlights a recent exchange of heavy artillery fire in Kurram district, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, between Pakistani troops and Afghan Taliban forces. Pakistani officials said Taliban border posts were destroyed in that clash.

The report adds that the groups Pakistan backed to protect its western frontier have now become some of its most serious security challenges. If the reports about arming new Afghan factions are confirmed, the report says, it would be a hazardous decision by a nuclear-armed state. It warns that Pakistan may end up creating fresh enemies in its effort to overcome threats it helped create earlier.