80 Years On, India Questions Relevance of WWII-Era UN Power
The United Nations must not be bound by the outcome of a conflict fought more than eight decades ago, India told the world body on Thursday. Permanent Representative P. Harish made the case at the UN General Assembly, saying the Security Council's composition no longer reflects global realities.
Harish stated that no war, particularly one that happened over 80 years ago, can define the current state of the world. In his view, the strength gained from a victory so long ago cannot fix the representation gap in the Security Council today.
The Security Council's permanent seats remain with the nations recognised as winners of the Second World War, he noted. India, he reminded delegates, was a significant contributor to that war effort.
He cited figures showing that around 2.5 million Indians participated in the conflict and about 90,000 Indian soldiers were killed. He also referred to the Bengal famine, linked to colonial policies during the war, which caused over 4 million deaths.
Harish said some actors prefer to ignore or downplay these facts.
He argued that an institution designed by victors, for victors, reflecting their perspective, naturally left out the voices of those who had suffered most.
The 1945 UN Charter, he said, gave victorious powers special rights that now allow some states to block reform. Yet these rights should not be used to keep Security Council reform talks in the Intergovernmental Negotiations (IGN) process suspended without end. Harish stressed that negotiations require a draft text, a deadline and a clear path forward.
He accused a small group led by Italy, including Pakistan, of using procedural tactics to stop the adoption of the draft text required to start talks. The group, Uniting for Consensus (UfC), insists that a draft must have consensus among all member states before it is adopted.
Harish said this reasoning was hard to follow. "In any multilateral process, you need a draft text to begin negotiations, not once negotiations have ended," he said.
He added that Security Council reform discussions, like other processes within the UN, should advance on the basis of a written draft.