Kaif Questions Iyer's Bowling Changes After Auckland Loss
Former India cricketer Mohammad Kaif has raised serious questions about Shreyas Iyer's captaincy following India's defeat to New Zealand in the fourth T20 International at Eden Park, Auckland.
Speaking after the match, Kaif pointed to a recurring issue rather than a one-off problem. He said Iyer's decisions on bowling changes and on the allocation of overs to specific bowlers had shown a clear pattern that needs urgent correction.
According to Kaif, teams are now routinely posting totals of 200, 225 and even 250 against India. He said the captain must develop a better understanding of how to handle specialist bowlers in different phases of an innings.
Kaif explained the roles India's key bowlers should play. Arshdeep Singh is the team's specialist left-arm option in the death overs, and Bhuvneshwar Kumar has the experience to handle both the new ball and the final over. Iyer, he said, should save these overs for the stages when batters are trying to accelerate. Kaif noted that the 17th and 19th overs are usually reserved for the strongest bowlers, a basic formula in T20 cricket.
He also highlighted a worrying statistic. Before 2026, India had never conceded 250 or more runs in a men's T20 innings. Since then, under Iyer, they have given away three such totals in four months. England scored 257 for 3 at Southampton, West Indies made 252 for 4 in Ranchi, and New Zealand reached 259 for 7 in Auckland.
Kaif, however, cautioned against placing all the blame on the captain. He said India's deployment of bowlers had also contributed to the problem. In Auckland, Nitish Kumar Reddy went for 64 runs in four overs, and Phillips and Bracewell put on 115 runs in 41 balls. New Zealand added 146 runs in the last nine overs as India's bowling could not contain the boundaries. Arshdeep was the only Indian bowler who gave away little.
The former cricketer also observed that while Arshdeep has been a consistent presence in the team, the bowling combinations around him have changed frequently. He suggested this could be one reason India are struggling to control the scoring rate.
Kaif further questioned the responsibility being handed to Nitish Kumar Reddy. In his view, the all-rounder is best suited as a fifth or sixth bowling option, with his overs ideally completed in the middle phase rather than expecting him to lead the attack.
Iyer's batting has also dipped. After an unbeaten 102 off 43 balls against West Indies in Lucknow on October 6, his scores in the last eight innings read 40, 1, 16, 22, 42, 7, 5 and 22.