Skip to content

Fish Out of Water: Ashwin Criticises India's No. 3 Call for Vaibhav

By News Analysis India · · 2 min read

New Delhi, October 25: Former India spinner R Ashwin has questioned India's decision to promote young batter Vaibhav Suryavanshi to number three in the second T20 International against New Zealand, arguing that the unfamiliar role hindered the batter's natural game.

The former off-spinner feels that if the think tank wants to field all three of these batters in the same playing eleven, Sanju Samson should be the one to shoulder the number three responsibility.

Suryavanshi got his first opportunity of the series in Christchurch after Ishan Kishan sustained an injury and was ruled out. The chance did not go according to plan. Suryavanshi scored just 4 runs from 8 balls, while Samson and Abhishek Sharma continued in their regular opening slots.

While discussing the match on his YouTube channel, Ashwin described the outing as a miss. He said it might be too early to judge a talented young player so harshly, but since he had only two options to choose from, hit or miss, the performance looked like a miss. He said Vaibhav appeared restless, like a fish taken out of water, and kept straining for big shots through those eight deliveries.

Ashwin's analysis centred on the challenge of adjusting to a different batting position rather than the number of runs scored. Suryavanshi is known for playing aggressively, but he could not find his rhythm against New Zealand. Ashwin believes a senior batter at the other end could have helped him settle.

He pointed out that the young batter did not seem to be picking up the ball cleanly. Ashwin said a batter in that situation often needs a simple reminder from a senior teammate to stay calm, keep the body close to the line of the ball and watch it more carefully. He also felt that coming in to bat in the sixth over did not suit Suryavanshi at all.

To solve India's team selection puzzle, Ashwin suggested that Samson, who had earlier batted at number three in a similar combination, could drop down the order. This would allow Suryavanshi to play a role more suited to his strengths.

The former spinner admitted he was not certain whether Vaibhav should continue at number three if the team sticks with this structure. However, he said the day had been a setback for the young batter.

The discussion comes at a time when India is testing its batting combinations in a five-match T20 International series. If Samson and Abhishek open the innings, the question of how to fit Suryavanshi into the side will remain significant in the matches ahead, particularly as the team wants to retain his attacking style without asking him to take on an unfamiliar role.

Despite Suryavanshi's difficulties, India's middle and lower-middle order provided plenty of positives in the second T20. Tilak Varma, Nitish Kumar Reddy and Naman Dhir played crucial roles as India completed the chase of New Zealand's 180-run target.