The Ethical Dilemma Of Helping He Who Was In Baldur's Gate 3

As players embark on their journey through the Ruined Battlefield in Baldur's Gate 3, they encounter a character known as He Who Was, a Drow engaging in dark and suspicious rituals. This scenario raises an intriguing question: should you assist this sinister figure? The choice players make could lead to various outcomes, shaping their adventure in unexpected ways. The quest titled Punished the Wicked sets the stage for a moral conundrum that challenges the player's sense of justice and consequence.

He Who Was stands out as a deeply complex character. Initially appearing emotionless and detached, he transforms into a sadistic torturer due to the Shadow Curse. This transformation adds layers to his personality, making players question his intentions and the morality of aiding him. As players delve deeper into the quest, they learn that He Who Was seeks to interrogate a corpse to uncover the true murderer, sparking a series of choices that can lead to very different endings.

Choosing to help He Who Was involves retracing the steps to the Waning Moon Inn to fetch a ledger that holds crucial information. Interestingly, the ledger reveals that while the corpse is guilty, her actions were not premeditated, adding a twist to the narrative. Players must weigh the implications of their decisions—will they stand by He Who Was and support his thirst for vengeance, or will they choose compassion for the guilty yet unsuspecting corpse? This pivotal moment invites players to reflect on their values and the consequences of their actions.

Exploring the Consequences of Your Choices

Once players decide to assist He Who Was, they are faced with multiple paths that lead to different outcomes. One option is to forgive the corpse's actions, which surprisingly results in an attack from He Who Was, forcing players to make a difficult choice between compassion and self-preservation. This moment highlights the unpredictability of the quest and tests players' moral compasses.

Alternatively, berating the character can lead to a different reward. He Who Was appreciates the harshness and rewards players with unique items, such as the Raven Gloves, which introduce new gameplay mechanics. This choice emphasizes the diversity of the game and the importance of player agency in shaping their experience.

Ultimately, players can opt to skip the fetch quest entirely and confront He Who Was directly. This decision not only influences the storyline but also provides an opportunity for character development and growth among party members, particularly with Shadowheart, who can gain inspiration from the encounter. Each decision intertwines player choices with character progression, creating an immersive narrative filled with ethical dilemmas.

Navigating the Ruined Battlefields: A Guide

Navigating the Ruined Battlefields is relatively straightforward, as it serves as an entry point into the Shadow-Cursed Lands. Players can access this location through notable sites like the Grymforge or Rosymorn Monastery. The coordinates X: 128 Y: 110 pinpoint where He Who Was can be found, along with the corpse of Madeline.

As players progress through this area, they will encounter familiar faces and additional quests that further enrich their journey. The choices made in this initial encounter can ripple throughout the game, affecting future interactions and character dynamics. This interconnectedness adds depth to the narrative, inviting players to explore the consequences of their actions fully.

In conclusion, the quest involving He Who Was presents a compelling exploration of morality, choice, and consequence in Baldur's Gate 3. Whether players choose to assist him, confront him, or take a more merciful approach, the outcomes are bound to create a memorable and impactful adventure. Each decision is a reflection of the player's values, making the game not just an exploration of a fantastical world, but also a journey into the heart of ethical dilemmas.