Skip to content

Court rules dismissal of constable Bharat Patta was illegal and arbitrary

By News Analysis India · · 1 min read

In a landmark decision, the Jharkhand High Court declared the removal of Constable Bharat Patta from the Jharkhand Armed Police unlawful. Justice Deepak Roshan examined the departmental paperwork and concluded that the dismissal was based on an accusation that never appeared in the official charge‑sheet.

The case originated when a married woman lodged a complaint in 2023, alleging that Patta had entered into a relationship with her while both were already married. She maintained that the liaison lasted from October 2019 to April 2023 and that Patta later abandoned the relationship.

After the complaint, the police department initiated a departmental probe and registered an FIR. Patta was first suspended and later terminated. The high court’s scrutiny revealed that the charge‑sheet only mentioned ‘indiscipline and maintaining a relationship with a married woman’. The decision to invoke the rape FIR as a justification was found to be outside the scope of the charge‑sheet.

Service regulations dictate that disciplinary action may only be taken on charges formally enumerated in a charge‑sheet. Because the criminal allegation was not part of that document, the court deemed the termination order invalid and ordered its cancellation.

During the hearing, the court observed that the complainant did not provide any concrete evidence—no marriage documents, CCTV recordings, or lease agreements—to corroborate her statements. The lack of tangible proof further weakened the department’s case.

Citing the Supreme Court’s Joseph Shine ruling, which removed adultery from the penal code, the bench highlighted that an alleged extramarital affair alone does not constitute a criminal offence and cannot justify severe departmental action.

The judgment restores Patta’s position in the police force and instructs the department to issue a written reprimand for the procedural lapse.