State Government Advises Governor to Reject Mercy Applications of Shubha Convicts
In a statement released on Thursday, Karnataka’s state government recommended that the governor dismiss the clemency petitions of Shubha Shankar Narayan and D. Arun Verma, both convicted for the 2003 Ring Road homicide.
The advice was given by Minister Priyamk Khadage, who oversees home affairs, information technology, biotechnology and e‑governance. He explained that the cabinet’s decision aligns with the Supreme Court’s earlier directive – a July 2025 order that allowed the petitioners eight weeks to file mercy pleas and instructed that they remain in custody without any further suspension of their sentences.
Article 161 of the Constitution empowers the governor to grant pardons, reprieves or remission. However, the cabinet’s review concluded that the severe nature of the crime, which involved a pre‑meditated murder of an engaged software engineer, warrants maintaining the original life sentences.
The Ring Road murder, which took place on December 3, 2003, involved the killing of B.V. Girish, a young software professional. Investigations revealed that Shubha, allegedly in a relationship with Arun Verma, colluded with two accomplices – Venkatesh and Dinesh – to orchestrate the killing. All four were convicted of murder and criminal conspiracy under Sections 302 and 120‑B of the IPC, receiving life imprisonment, a verdict upheld by the Karnataka High Court and later affirmed by the Supreme Court.