Skip to content

SP MP Nadvi: Opposition Protests Are a Constitutional Right

By News Analysis India · · 3 min read

New Delhi, October 24: Samajwadi Party MP Mohibullah Nadvi has defended the opposition's street protests, describing them as a constitutional right. Speaking to reporters, he said the public is currently anxious and that the Constitution creates space for the opposition to act as a check on the ruling party when it becomes arrogant.

According to Nadvi, the opposition exists to point out when the ruling party drifts from constitutional principles. He said its job is to carry the aspirations and emotions of ordinary people to those in power, so that the government accepts its mistakes and changes course. He called this a legitimate and democratic method.

The SP leader pointed to Akhilesh Yadav and Rahul Gandhi as the two prominent faces of the opposition in recent days. He noted that both are Leaders of the Opposition and that his party has the second-largest majority in the LoP's position after the largest party. He added that the grouping known as the INDIA bloc came together during the Waqf Amendment Bill vote, when parties united to reject the bill in defence of the Constitution and democracy.

Nadvi said that after several meetings, every opposition party shares one aim: to make sure the ruling party stops repeating its errors and disregarding the Constitution. He argued that public restlessness was natural, given that crores of voters had been removed from electoral rolls.

He referred to a report from Delhi claiming that ten living people had been shown as dead. He said it was regrettable that courts were treating such lapses as matters to be fixed in future elections. He questioned the legitimacy of a government formed in this manner, citing Lakhimpur Kheri, where he said 10,000 votes were found and the BJP won by 6,000. If errors of that size occurred, he asked, was that not wrong?

Nadvi compared the issue to taking someone's land or rights unfairly and then promising to correct it later. He said this was not logic but a 'might is right' mindset. A wrong, he said, remains a wrong.

He praised the children who gathered at Jantar Mantar for presenting a clear vision of India, and said the nation should learn from them. He lamented that Hindus and Muslims remain divided and recalled remarks by ITBP Director Shatrujeet Singh Kapoor about India lagging behind China in weapons. Nadvi said India had never treated China as a true rival, even though China had attacked it twice.

He argued that India had wasted its energy on Hindu-Muslim tensions and Kashmir, and questioned why the country measured itself against Pakistan, Bangladesh, Myanmar or Bhutan rather than major global powers. He said India needed advanced weapons and a merit-based social structure, and accused the system of corruption, including paper leaks that he said helped certain groups gain admission.

Nadvi also recalled a discussion with former Home Minister P Chidambaram on Kashmir. He said he had urged that Kashmiris receive the same freedoms as people in other states and that their grievances be addressed. He asked whether Kashmiri students could study freely in national universities and whether Kashmiri traders could sell their goods without trouble.

He concluded by saying Kashmiris are part of the nation, pointing to Adil Shah, who gave his life to protect fellow citizens, and to Kashmiri soldiers in the Kargil war. He said hatred based on religion, colour or race must end, and that every poor, weak or illiterate citizen, including a Brahmin, deserves equal dignity and opportunities. If the law does not provide for this, he said, it should.