Skip to content

Shiv Sena internal split over 'Tir-Kaman' symbol examined by top judges

By News Analysis India · · 1 min read

The Supreme Court on Wednesday scrutinised the factional battle within Shiv Sena over ownership of the party's iconic "Tir‑Kaman" symbol. The dispute, which began after the 2018 party congress, saw the Uddhav Thackeray group appointing a "party chief" through an internal election, while the Eknath Shinde faction challenged the legitimacy of that process.

Senior lawyer Kapil Sibbal presented the Thackeray side's case, citing the Representation of the People Act, 1951, Section 29A, sub‑clause 9, which mandates parties to inform the Election Commission of any alteration in name, headquarters, or office‑bearers. He asserted that the party had promptly notified the commission, providing a sealed document bearing the commission's seal.

Justice B. Gagci probed the timing of the leadership change, asking whether the number of elected members had shifted in February. Sibbal replied that the party had supplied a complete list of both nominated and elected officials, and that the party constitution explicitly requires the "party chief" to be elected by the executive committee.

The bench also debated whether the Election Commission possessed the authority to adjudicate internal party matters. Chief Justice Surya Kant remarked that jurisdiction depends on whether the commission's powers were invoked correctly; a misuse of power would be a distinct issue from lack of jurisdiction.

The hearing was postponed to Thursday for further arguments, with the court signalling that a definitive ruling on the commission's role could have far‑reaching implications for party governance across India.