Skip to content

Shahabuddin Rejects Claim That Indian Muslims Are Second-Class Citizens

By News Analysis India · · 2 min read

Bareilly, October 31: Maulana Shahabuddin has openly disagreed with the statement given by Maulana Mahmood Madani, president of Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind, regarding the status of Muslims in India. Shahabuddin asserted that Muslims in the country are not second-class citizens but enjoy the status of first-class citizens with equal rights and religious freedom.

According to Shahabuddin, Muslims in India are free to do business, participate in religious functions and lead their lives according to their customs. He appealed to the public to understand the real situation of the nation through a positive lens instead of focusing only on negativity.

He told reporters that Madani should recognise the freedom that Muslims enjoy in India. Like other citizens, they lead respectable and ordinary lives, Shahabuddin said. Muslims, he added, are free to observe their religious rituals, run their trades and organise their daily routines as they see fit.

Shahabuddin listed several examples of religious freedom. Muslims offer namaz five times a day and celebrate Eid, Bakrid and Eid Milad-un-Nabi, in addition to observing Friday prayers. Muharram, Juloos-e-Gausia and other religious processions are also held in keeping with local traditions. He said Muslims enjoy full liberty in performing these events and following Islamic practices.

He further stated that Muslim educational institutions and other religious centres operate independently. These institutions, he said, are not under the watch of the government or controlled by any non-Muslim. Hence, calling Muslims in India second-class citizens is not appropriate, he said, adding that such thinking is rooted in negativity and spreads confusion in society.

Shahabuddin admitted that one or two such incidents have occurred in the country. Still, he said, occasional incidents are possible in a country with such a vast population. Mentioning that India has around 145 crore people, he stressed that no single incident should be used to judge the entire population or any one community.

He also cautioned against viewing these incidents through the prism of Hindu-Muslim or BJP-Congress politics. Shahabuddin pointed out that similar events took place under Muslim rulers, who also struggled to control them, and during British rule. Therefore, he said, forming a general negative opinion about the country or a community based on isolated events is unjustified.

He urged citizens to adopt a positive approach and view the position of Muslims in India with an open mind. The strength of the nation, he said, lies in people of different faiths and communities living together with freedom. Muslims, he said, should not live in fear. He recalled that India is the homeland of their elders and that their ancestors contributed to the independence movement. Hence, he said, there is no reason for them to feel anxious about their citizenship or rights, and he reiterated that labelling Muslims as second-class citizens is wrong.