Setback for Mahua Moitra as SC Dismisses AIF, FPI Transparency Plea
The Supreme Court has refused to hear a petition filed by Trinamool Congress MP Mahua Moitra, seeking greater transparency around foreign investment vehicles operating in India. The matter was heard on Thursday, and the court disposed of the writ petition without granting the relief requested.
The petition had asked the Securities and Exchange Board of India to make public the full details of ultimate beneficial owners and investment portfolios of Alternative Investment Funds, Foreign Portfolio Investors and their intermediaries. The bench, headed by Justice B.V. Nagarathna and including Justices R. Mahadevan and D.K. Upadhyay, held that no legal or regulatory framework currently requires such disclosure.
The court said that without any such framework, it could not, in exercise of its discretion, issue a writ of mandamus under Article 32 of the Constitution directing the respondent authorities to disclose such information in full.
Although the petition was not entertained on merits, the court gave Moitra liberty to approach the Union government and SEBI regarding the grievances she had raised. The bench made clear that the petitioner could pursue the issues before the concerned authorities.
Arguing the case, Prashant Bhushan said that substantial investments were flowing into Indian companies through foreign entities even as the real investors remained unidentified. According to him, this opacity risked violations of SEBI norms and could enable market manipulation by institutions deploying large amounts of capital. He also pointed out that beneficial ownership disclosure is mandatory in many countries.
The bench, however, questioned whether the court could issue such a direction when no policy mandating the proposed disclosures existed. Justice Nagarathna observed that enforcing an existing disclosure requirement through mandamus would stand on a different footing.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta opposed the plea, arguing that its real aim was to stop foreign investment from coming into the country. Bhushan countered that revealing ultimate beneficial owners would not cause any loss to lawful investment.
The court noted in its order that AIFs and FPIs already provide investment details to SEBI or custodians, allowing regulatory monitoring. It stressed, however, that no existing law requires entity-wise investments to be disclosed publicly.