Skip to content

Senior judges' open letter sparks NDA criticism of Election Commission

By News Analysis India · · 1 min read

In New Delhi on October 9, a collective open letter from 42 former judges raised concerns about the Election Commission’s handling of the voter list and alleged external influence. The NDA quickly responded, framing the letter as evidence of a foreign‑backed “India Block” interfering with India’s democratic mechanisms.

Pramod Kumar, a minister in the Bihar government, suggested that the judges must have discovered a plot, hinting that the India Block works on instructions from abroad. He questioned Rahul Gandhi’s foreign contacts, implying that undisclosed meetings could shape domestic politics.

Shravan Kumar, another Bihar minister, warned against indiscriminate criticism of constitutional institutions. He asserted that while citizens may voice dissent, those seeking to steer the nation must stay within constitutional limits.

BJP figures such as Pratul Shahdev argued that the Election Commission is exercising its constitutionally granted powers. He pointed out that 28 million deceased voters have already been removed from the electoral roll, indicating procedural compliance.

Mrityunjay Tiwari added that questioning the commission directly threatens democracy, accusing opposition leaders of staging street dramas to create unrest.

Gurdeep Prakash labeled the episode a "deliberate conspiracy" designed to slow the country’s progress, while Santosh Pandey stressed that only credible voices should influence the democratic process, dismissing baseless claims about Rohingya or Bangladeshi voters.