Skip to content

SC Slams Sabarimala PIL Filer: 'Abuse of Process' in Temple Row

Supreme Court justices unleashed tough scrutiny Tuesday on the lawyers' outfit that ignited the Sabarimala controversy via PIL, branding it potential 'legal abuse.' CJI Suryakant’s nine-judge panel,...

By News Analysis India · · Updated · 1 min read

Supreme Court justices unleashed tough scrutiny Tuesday on the lawyers' outfit that ignited the Sabarimala controversy via PIL, branding it potential 'legal abuse.' CJI Suryakant’s nine-judge panel, including heavyweights like Justice Nagarathna and Sundresh, hammered advocate Gupta on legitimacy during the review. 'You? Intervening in rituals? Why the obsession?' Justice Nagarathna grilled, rejecting a lawyers' collective's claim to puja rights or tradition tweaks. The PIL's shaky basis—media reports—earned CJI's scorn: 'Purely rejectable.' Authorization gaps fueled outrage. With ex-president Ali sidelined and uninformed, Justice Sundresh quipped he'd never endorse this if engaged. Non-faithful challengers? Unacceptable, per Nagarathna: Courts won't back ritual wreckers. Gupta pushed back: Age ban insults femininity, defies religious freedom clauses. But 2018's nod mooted standing, he claimed. Historical myths on Ayyappa? Court shut it down—'Stick to law.' No factual rehash of prior ruling. Context: Post-2018 protests rocked Kerala over women entry. Now, apex court weighs faith protections against rights, custom review limits, sect privileges. This episode signals judicial wariness, prioritizing authentic representation in sanctity disputes.