SC Slams Lawyers' Group in Sabarimala Case: Focus on Real Issues
A nine-judge powerhouse at the Supreme Court unleashed a barrage of questions on the Indian Lawyers Association, the pioneer litigant in the Sabarimala women's entry controversy. During intense...
A nine-judge powerhouse at the Supreme Court unleashed a barrage of questions on the Indian Lawyers Association, the pioneer litigant in the Sabarimala women's entry controversy. During intense arguments, the bench challenged their authority to meddle in sacred rituals, humorously asking if they donned priestly robes. At heart, the battle rages over Kerala’s Sabarimala temple's ban on women between 10 and 50 years, rooted in beliefs tied to the deity's celibate vow. Fast-forward from the 2006 petition to 2018's landmark 4:1 nod for universal access, now under review. The court flagged the PIL as misuse, with Justice BV Nagarathna quipping it's morphed into 'private interest, money, and media spotlight' litigation. She urged the association to champion welfare for young advocates instead. Representing petitioners, advocate Ravi Prakash Gupta fired back at priests' deity preference claims, deeming them offensive to Lord Ayyappa's ethos. He argued such rhetoric wounds women's dignity beyond faith lines. Judges doubled down, with Justice Arvind Kumar demanding proof of internal authorization for the suit—only to hear of absent formal approvals. Collective judicial frown highlighted risks of PIL proliferation overburdening courts. This hearing peels back layers on judicial overreach into religious domains, balancing Article 25 freedoms against equality mandates. Sabarimala's global devotees hold breath as traditions clash with modern rights. From protests to petitions, the case symbolizes India's evolving secular fabric. The bench's stance signals caution against opportunistic filings, potentially curbing future religious interventions. Outcomes here could echo across temples, mosques, and churches, shaping precedents for faith-based disputes in the world's largest democracy.