Religious Leaders Clash Over 'Vande Mataram' Lyrics Controversy
NEW DELHI, September 3 — A fresh dispute over the words of "Vande Mataram" erupted after Geetanjali Angmo, the spouse of activist Sonam Wangchuk, asked whether followers of non‑Hindu faiths could comfortably render a song that mentions Hindu gods.
Maulana Sajid Rashedi, who heads the All India Imams Association, replied with a stern denunciation. He explained that ghazals are artistic expressions of romance, not acts of worship, and that drawing parallels with the national song is factually incorrect. According to Rashedi, Islam forbids Muslims from singing the composition, regardless of any governmental directive.
The Maulana invoked constitutional safeguards, stating that the right to abstain from any practice contrary to one's religion is protected by law. He warned that even a presidential decree would not alter Muslim sentiment.
The controversy prompted reactions from political quarters. Aam Aadmi Party leader Priyanka Kakkar emphasized the need to obey the law, while a BJP spokesperson defended Angmo’s stance, pointing out that the mention of Goddess Durga in the lyrics celebrates bravery rather than religious endorsement.
Analysts say the episode underscores the ongoing tension between patriotic symbolism and India’s religious diversity.