Ramesh Exposes Great Nicobar EIA as 'Scientific Mockery'
Renowned environmentalist and Congress MP Jairam Ramesh has leveled explosive charges against the Great Nicobar Infrastructure Project, writing urgently to the Environment Ministry. In his missive,...
Renowned environmentalist and Congress MP Jairam Ramesh has leveled explosive charges against the Great Nicobar Infrastructure Project, writing urgently to the Environment Ministry. In his missive, he brands the EIA process a sham—superficial studies masquerading as due diligence in one of India's most pristine ecosystems. The controversy brews amid government claims of thorough environmental management, via a May 1 FAQ. Ramesh's May 3 rebuttal escalated with this latest salvo, unpacking regulatory violations galore. For ports over 5 million TPA in fragile territories, EIA norms—from 2009 office memos—mandate three-season scrutiny, modeling, and fieldwork. Reality check: Baseline data scraped from a single winter span. Biodiversity scans? Token 14-22 December 2020. Leatherback surveys? Six days in February 2021. The EIA candidly admits forest density curtailed surveys, with uncharted realms potentially harboring critical lifeforms. Galathea Bay's ISRO-identified erosion status screamed for amplified coastal probes under CRZ rules—ignored. Ramesh cites Javadekar's 2015 Lok Sabha rebuff of rapid EIAs, echoing that brevity blinds to true threats. Even Zoological Survey and WII efforts were fleeting; ANIIDCO docs bare the brevity. Clearance on this basis? 'Vijñān kā apamān'—science's dishonor, Ramesh roars. NGT's April 2023 verdict flagged lapses, birthing an HPC; its secrecy defies transparency norms. Release it, he demands, for accountable governance. At stake: Great Nicobar's unparalleled biodiversity, imperiled by unchecked development. Ramesh rejects afforestation offsets as misguided, noting defense voices favoring eco-friendly alternatives. A compelling case for project overhaul emerges, urging balance between progress and preservation.