Patna HC Overturns Conviction, Citing Lack of Evidence for Rape Attempt
The Patna High Court, on July 9, revisited a 2008 case involving Himanshu Kumar Patel (also known as Mithia Patel) and annulled the lower court’s conviction. The trial court had sentenced the accused to three years under Sections 376/511 and six months under Section 342 after finding him guilty of rape attempt and assault.
The High Court re‑examined the evidence and held that the prosecution failed to prove essential elements of an attempted rape, such as penetration or medical proof of sexual assault. Justice Purnendu Singh, sitting alone, noted the absence of any forensic evidence and observed that the investigation officer had not been cross‑examined during trial.
While the court acknowledged that the accused locked the studio door, stripped the victim’s clothing, and engaged in physical molestation, it concluded that these acts satisfied the criteria of Section 354 – outraging a woman's modesty – but did not rise to the level of an attempted rape under Sections 376 and 511.