Skip to content

NDA Leaders Hit Back at Naseeruddin Shah's Mahabharata Views

By News Analysis India · · 2 min read

New Delhi, October 25: A fresh controversy has erupted after actor Naseeruddin Shah made comments about the Mahabharata and Jamia students. His statements have triggered a wave of reactions from BJP leaders, while some opposition figures have come out in his support.

BJP leader Ram Kadam praised Shah's acting skills but said his views on the Mahabharata appeared to echo the voice of a Pakistani political leader. He questioned whether the actor was supporting the 'tukde-tukde gang', a term he used for groups he accused of working against the nation. Kadam also cited the case of Umar Khalid, who he said faced allegations in connection with the Delhi riots, including arson and attacks on residents. He further alleged that Shah stood with people who glorify Afzal Guru, who was linked to the attack on Parliament.

Party spokesperson Keya Ghosh questioned the credibility of Shah's claims. She said the people he described as students had completed their studies years ago but were still on campus. According to her, graffiti containing abusive language against the Prime Minister and the Chief Minister reflected behaviour that could not be expected from students. Ghosh also accused a group of occupying the Vice Chancellor's office for three days.

She took aim at the actor's family background as well, alleging that his relatives were connected with leftist politics. She mentioned that his niece had contested as a CPI(M) candidate and that her husband had also been a leftist candidate, and that both had lost elections twice before she moved to London. Ghosh argued that the family, despite Shah's apparent socialist leanings, believed in capitalism. She added that the BJP's victory in West Bengal appeared difficult for him to accept.

BJP leader Virendra Sachdeva said the actor had received immense affection and respect from the country. He said he had no hesitation in saying that the statements made by Farooq Abdullah and Naseeruddin Shah were troubling. He claimed that some people benefit from India but speak in favour of Pakistan, and suggested that such individuals should reflect on how they ought to be treated.

AITC MP Saugata Roy defended Shah, calling him a great artist and saying that his remarks were correct. He said he fully supported the actor.

JD(U) national spokesperson Rajiv Ranjan said Shah was recognised as an actor whose talent is respected worldwide. He noted that the actor has millions of admirers across India and urged leaders to consider their feelings. Ranjan said that a mature artist like Naseeruddin Shah should be able to distinguish between dissent and anarchy.

The debate is likely to continue as leaders from different parties weigh in on the boundaries of public expression.