Skip to content

Mann Urges Scrapping of SIR, Calls Vote Theft a Democratic Threat

By News Analysis India · · 3 min read

Chandigarh, October 23: Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann on Friday warned that 'vote theft' was endangering the foundations of Indian democracy. Demanding that the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voter lists be cancelled, he called for a fair investigation into the process and strict punishment for those found responsible for irregularities.

Speaking in the Assembly, Mann accused the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) of tampering with voter rolls under the Election Commission's name. He alleged that the party was adding votes in its favour and removing those of its rivals. Mann further claimed that elections held in Bihar, West Bengal, Haryana and Maharashtra had been won through 'vote theft'.

The Chief Minister argued that the country had arrived at a point where a government chosen by the people was now determining who may vote. He cautioned that authoritarian tendencies had taken hold of all four pillars of democracy.

After his speech, the Assembly adopted a resolution opposing the SIR by voice vote. The resolution, which Mann described as an act of 'dhakkashahi' that threatens citizens' voting rights, reflects the state's collective objection to the exercise.

During the debate on a resolution to protect citizens' voting rights amid the ongoing SIR, Mann said Punjab had set an example for the rest of the country by passing a resolution condemning the process. He stressed that every eligible citizen must be able to vote without the fear of being excluded arbitrarily.

"Voting rights are not a favour granted by any government. They form the basis of democratic participation. No eligible citizen should face unnecessary difficulty or arbitrary treatment in proving their eligibility," he said.

Mann noted that the Constitution, as envisioned by B.R. Ambedkar, guarantees equality, dignity and political participation to all citizens. He voiced concern about names being removed from voter lists in ways that affect particular sections of society and called for full transparency and an impartial probe into the revision exercise.

"Whatever process decides who can exercise the right to vote must be transparent, fair and accountable. Protecting the vote of every eligible citizen is necessary to preserve the foundations of Indian democracy," Mann said.

He asked why objections had surfaced only after protests broke out in an assembly constituency, and why the Election Commission had now chosen to formally document the details of its meetings. He also pointed to disagreements among election commissioners regarding the commission's decision-making, demanding the highest standards of public scrutiny.

Mann criticised the Union government, led by the BJP, for the conduct of central agencies such as the Enforcement Directorate and the Central Bureau of Investigation. He said constitutional and investigative bodies should operate independently and free from political pressure.

"The country faces a straightforward question: will India remain a democracy where every vote counts, or will we allow a system where those in power decide whose voice deserves to be heard?" Mann asked.

The Chief Minister also expressed unease over the Centre's response to Punjab's efforts to draw international investment. "I am presenting Punjab to global business leaders as a preferred destination for investment, showcasing its industrial strength, skilled manpower and entrepreneurial spirit," he said.

Mann said that obstacles had been placed in the way of a proposed foreign visit intended to promote investment opportunities in Punjab. The action taken against him, he said, raised questions that demanded a careful inquiry. He further raised concerns about the customs establishment and emphasised the need for transparency and accountability in institutional functioning.

"Punjab's economic growth should not become a hostage to political disputes. Investment, jobs and prosperity are directly tied to the future of our young people. Every attempt to attract investment and generate opportunities must be encouraged," the Chief Minister said.