Legal Challenge Demands Guidelines to Stop Political Campaigns Targeting Judges
A petition lodged before the Supreme Court on October 13, 2024 calls for the issuance of clear guidelines to curb political campaigns that single out members of the judiciary. The petition was prompted by a social‑media entry from the Kerala wing of the Congress party, which publicly addressed Chief Justice of India Sunil Kumar Suryakant and urged him to step down if he could not maintain law and order.
Petitioners argue that such direct appeals constitute an attempt to exert undue influence over the chief justice, violating the principle of judicial independence guaranteed by the Constitution. They cite Article 121 and the removal provisions of Article 124(4), asserting that any action against a sitting judge must follow the established constitutional process.
The document lists the central government, senior Congress figures, and the Kerala Pradesh Congress Committee as respondents, accusing them of orchestrating a coordinated public pressure campaign. The petitioners seek a court order that would bar political parties from using social media or other public platforms to demand the resignation or replacement of judges.
Legal analysts note that while political commentary is a core democratic right, it must not cross the line into intimidation. A ruling in favour of the petition could reinforce the boundary between legitimate criticism and contempt, thereby safeguarding the judiciary from future political encroachments.