Petition questions Karnataka government's two-verse rule for national song
Bengaluru, 22 September – A public interest petition filed by senior advocate Girish Bhardwaj has brought the Karnataka government's directive to limit Vande Matrm to two verses under judicial scrutiny.
The petition, heard by a division bench led by Justice Anu Shivraman, argues that the authority to frame guidelines for the national anthem and national song resides solely with the Centre. Angad Kamat, who appeared for the petitioner, highlighted that the Ministry of Home Affairs has already issued detailed instructions on how the anthem and the song should be performed.
Kamat noted that Vande Matrm comprises six verses and that any unilateral truncation by a state cabinet is void unless backed by a formal cabinet note and inter‑departmental consensus. He pointed out the absence of any such documentation in the Karnataka order.
Advocate General Shashi Kiran Shetty, on behalf of the state, countered that the petition was filed on a holiday and sought immediate hearing, implying a lack of seriousness. Shetty also cited Supreme Court pronouncements that while the anthem must be sung, the national song is not compulsory in its entirety.
The state’s position is further supported by a letter from the Central Government’s Joint Secretary to Chief Secretaries, which outlines specific occasions suitable for playing the full Vande Matrm but also acknowledges the practice of using only two verses for routine events.
Political undertones have intensified the dispute. The Union Education Minister warned that the issue would be raised in Parliament, and opposition legislators recently sang the complete Vande Matrm in the Karnataka Assembly, directly contravening the state’s two‑verse directive.