Skip to content

India’s Constitution Cited as Shield Against Foreign Religious‑Freedom Critique

By News Analysis India · · 1 min read

In a forceful rebuttal, Shiv Sena’s Shaina N.C. dismissed a social‑media post by the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) that discussed the Sharjeel Imam case. She emphasized that India’s legal framework—its constitution, statutes and judicial system—already guarantees freedom of worship.

"We have our own courts and legal provisions; no outside party can tell us how to protect religious rights," Shaina declared. She praised the long‑standing Indian tradition of celebrating multiple festivals together, from Ganesh Chaturthi to Eid, Guru Nanak’s birthday and Christmas, as evidence of the nation’s inclusive ethos.

The leader warned the United States to focus on its domestic religious‑freedom challenges, noting that Islam’s followers number around 200 million in India and are not collectively incarcerated. She urged an end to unfounded rumors and stressed that Indian institutions will continue to function without external pressure.

The controversy follows previous objections raised by Indian Ambassador Vinay Mohan Kwatra to the USCIRF’s statements, a sentiment reinforced by RP Singh who affirmed that foreign organizations cannot meddle in India’s internal affairs. The matter is now before an Indian court, with the Supreme Court’s eventual decision expected to set a definitive precedent, overriding any foreign commentary.