HC Asks Kerala Govt to Explain RTI Curbs on Vigilance Records
Kochi: The Kerala High Court has asked the state government to explain whether inquiries into government officials conducted by the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau (VACB) are covered by the RTI exemption granted to two of its sections.
Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice V.M. Shyam Kumar, hearing the matter on Wednesday, directed the government to submit an affidavit. It must detail the types of information handled by the T1 and T2 sections, which were placed under exemption through a notification dated October 22.
The bench noted that these sections handle vigilance inquiries, intelligence inputs, search reports and other records linked to vigilance action. While acknowledging that some of this material may be sensitive, the court asked whether probes against officers fall within the exemption's ambit.
The court will revisit the issue after three weeks.
The case is a public interest litigation that questions the government's move to bring these two sections under the exemption.
The petitioner's core argument is that the VACB functions mainly as a criminal investigation body that examines corruption cases involving public servants. Such an agency, the petitioner says, cannot be reclassified as an intelligence or security organisation through an administrative notification alone.
Under Section 24(4) of the RTI Act, state governments may exempt specified intelligence and security organisations through a notification published in the Official Gazette. The petitioner highlighted that the VACB did not feature in the list of eight organisations exempted by a government order issued on February 7, 2006.
According to the petition, VACB information officers have begun turning down requests on vigilance inquiries, preliminary verifications, closure reports and prosecution sanctions, citing the October 22 notification.
The petition also stresses that the RTI Act already provides safeguards for sensitive information, such as material whose release could obstruct an inquiry or threaten lives. Full exemption for the two sections, it contends, could weaken public scrutiny of the state's anti-corruption apparatus.
In court, the petitioner cited a recent Supreme Court ruling in Special Police Establishment v. Kamta Prasad Mishra and Others, arguing that a corruption-investigating agency cannot be considered an intelligence or security organisation under Section 24(4) by default.
The petitioner further pointed out that the state government had withdrawn a comparable notification in 2016 after it faced a challenge in the High Court.
The petition asks the court to set aside the October 22 notification and keep the RTI Act applicable to the two sections, so that information not covered by statutory exemptions remains accessible. The High Court has yet to decide on the notification's legality.