Frank Calls for Bigger Investment in India's Research Base
New Delhi, October 27: As the world debates the future of technology and scientific research, Nobel Prize winner Professor Joachim Frank of Columbia University in New York has made a notable observation about India's role. He shared his vision on the basic needs India must address to become the next major power in science and innovation, and on the path young researchers should follow.
Professor Frank said he had not known the full dimensions of the venture he has joined. He described the discussion of the future through the lens of technology as a highly effective approach. Looking at India, he said it is clearly a subcontinent offering enormous opportunity and capacity, particularly in its people. What is truly needed, he said, is hardware technology.
Drawing on his own field, he explained that cryo-electron microscopy is the key technique. He noted that only six instruments exist for the many people who want to perform cryo-electron microscopy. For India to become competitive, he believes the number should be raised to at least 20 or more.
On artificial intelligence in scientific research, he described AI as a helper, not a driving force. He said there is a great deal of misunderstanding about its abilities and that pursuing this route is very dangerous. For him and many other science-trained professionals, science is based on experience, and AI can play only an auxiliary role.
While AI has a far greater capacity to process massive datasets and detect patterns, he said its abilities have been widely misunderstood. It cannot be autonomous, and it should not be. It can only serve in a supporting capacity. He gave the example of structural biology, where AI needs training data. X-ray crystallography and cryo-EM have produced vast amounts of data over decades, and AI has learned from it. However, many major research fields have no data at all, and AI there is completely blind. It cannot generate anything because no data has been provided to it.
He said basic science and proper instruments are extremely important for India. He had already commented on the state of structural biology. While investment has been made in X-ray crystallography, cryo-electron microscopy, which is the emerging technology for drug development and related work, has very few available instruments. He described the situation as nearly negligible. With such limited investment, he said India will need a long time to catch up.
Advising scientists on their greatest challenges, he said the age of the internet and social networks has brought an avalanche of information. For young researchers in particular, choosing the right direction has become difficult. They often do not know which path to follow or what matters most for society. He urged people to focus on problems the world faces, such as global warming and challenges related to fair perspectives and political conditions. Solutions to these issues require investment, and they must be presented so that young scientists see clear routes forward.
Professor Frank recalled that when he started as a scientist, he faced similar uncertainty. He could not find a path, and there was not enough information to show him where to go. There was no internet. People had to visit public libraries to read the summaries of conferences they attended. He found his own way very gradually. Today, he said, the situation is the opposite. With information flooding in, finding one's own path can be extremely hard.
On increasing India's world-class scientific discoveries, he said it is vital that investment goes where it will have the greatest impact. National resource centres should be set up where people can send their samples. He emphasised that structural biology is a very important field for advancing molecular medicine. In his opinion, medicine should truly move toward personalised, fully individual-centred treatment, because medicines are currently designed for an imaginary average person.