Skip to content

Ex‑Election Commissioner Rejects Joint Secretary Offer, Cites Muslim Officer Scrutiny

By News Analysis India · · 1 min read

In a candid interview on July 14, former Chief Election Commissioner S.Y. Qureshi revealed that he refused a joint secretary position in the Prime Minister’s Office. The IAS officer, who had previously overseen the Youth Affairs and Sports Ministry, the Nehru Yuva Kendra Sangathan and the National Service Scheme, said his decision was driven by a desire to be evaluated on merit rather than on his faith.

Qureshi highlighted that his role in the youth portfolio involved managing three lakh youth clubs nationwide and coordinating NSS activities across 300 universities. This dual exposure to secretarial work and field operations, he noted, made his job “exceptional” and rewarding.

When the prospect of moving to the PMO arose, the information reached him through an unofficial source. He learned that his security clearance had already been processed and that an appointment order could arrive at any moment.

The former CEC expressed a longstanding apprehension about serving in ministries such as the PMO, Home and Defence, fearing that a Muslim officer might be placed under extra surveillance. He rejected any notion of being appointed under a “quota” based on religion.

During a meeting with the PMO’s additional secretary N.K. Sinha, Qureshi made it clear that he would only consider the role if he could join as a competent officer, not as a representative of the Muslim community. He offered alternative names for positions dealing with waqf matters, suggesting that a director‑grade officer could fulfil those duties.

According to Qureshi, K.R. Venugopal, the prime minister’s secretary at the time, backed his viewpoint. Venugopal had initially put Qureshi’s name forward six months earlier, but the existence of another Muslim officer in the PMO led to the proposal being withdrawn, and the incumbent’s tenure was extended for two more years.

The entire episode is chronicled in Qureshi’s latest publication, “India and I: A Hundred Memories, Not a Memoir,” where he reflects on his career and the challenges of navigating identity politics within the bureaucracy.