Skip to content

Election Commission Rejects Claims of CEC's Unilateral Decisions

By News Analysis India · · 1 min read

The Election Commission of India has responded to petitions in the Supreme Court by filing an affidavit that rejects claims about the unilateral functioning of the Chief Election Commissioner. The affidavit, dated October 26 from New Delhi, asserts that the commission's recent Special Intensive Revision orders were arrived at collectively.

The commission told the court that its three SIR orders, issued in June 2025, October 2025 and May 2026, were all unanimous decisions. It said the counter-affidavit was approved by the Chief Election Commissioner and both Election Commissioners together.

The filing responds to petitions from 13 opposition leaders, among them Rahul Gandhi, who is the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha and a Congress MP. The petitions question the functioning of the commission and the SIR exercise across several states.

In a joint response, the Election Commission, the Chief Election Commissioner and both Election Commissioners filed the affidavit together. The commission argued that the petition rests on one news report alone.

The affidavit specifically disputes the claim that CEC Gyanesh Kumar was taking one-sided decisions, describing that report as inaccurate.

To explain how decisions move within the commission, the affidavit described the file system. A file travels first to one Election Commissioner, then to the second, and then to the Chief Election Commissioner. According to the document, notes and questions raised during this process do not amount to decisions.

The affidavit further detailed the July events. The July 28 order was issued by an Additional Secretary, and both Election Commissioners wrote to the Cabinet Secretary the next day. Following a joint instruction from both Commissioners on July 30, the order was not implemented.

On Form 6, the commission clarified that there has been no change. It said only the government has the power to alter the form. The SIR declaration, it noted, is a distinct document. Starting October 21, the online process will also be split into two sections, Form 6 and the declaration.