Skip to content

Election Commission Defends SIR Decisions in Supreme Court Affidavit

By News Analysis India · · 2 min read

The Election Commission has told the Supreme Court that its three Special Intensive Revision (SIR) orders, issued in June 2025, October 2025 and May 2026, were arrived at by consensus. The poll body has filed an affidavit responding to petitions that question the conduct of the Chief Election Commissioner.

In the affidavit, the commission admitted that a viewer of the online form could have assumed it had been amended. From October 21, the online application will display Form 6 and the declaration separately, mirroring the physical form.

Voters who cannot be mapped to existing records will not be required to appear personally for hearings. Booth Level Officers will visit their homes to gather documents. Hearings will take place only in exceptional cases and, where feasible, will be held online.

According to the ECI, no name is added to or deleted from the voter list without an order from the Electoral Registration Officer. To verify compliance with the rules, a committee comprising experts from IIT and IISc has been formed.

In its response on the Goa matter, the commission said that of the 97 voters left out, 88 were already on the voter list, six were living abroad and three held Portuguese passports.

On appeals from West Bengal, the commission clarified that the objections to inclusion of names were filed by officers of the Chief Electoral Officer's office in West Bengal, acting under Supreme Court directions. These matters, it said, were not placed before the commission.

The poll body questioned the maintainability of the petition and argued that removing a CEC is a process comparable to removing a Supreme Court judge. It also rejected the suggestion that internal documents had been leaked, stating that no internal note or file was released to the media or authorised for release.

On EVM-related petitions, the commission pointed out that the Supreme Court has repeatedly rejected challenges to electronic voting machines. Because of the Dussehra holiday, it has submitted a short reply and requested permission to file a detailed, point-by-point response later.

The affidavit was filed in response to petitions by 13 opposition leaders, including Rahul Gandhi, Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha and a Congress MP, concerning the commission's functioning and the SIR across states. The Chief Election Commissioner and both Election Commissioners jointly approved the reply.

The commission said the petition rests on one news report and denied that CEC Gyanesh Kumar made one-sided decisions. It explained that files pass from one Election Commissioner to the other and then to the CEC, and that notes and questions do not amount to decisions.

As per the affidavit, a July 28 order was issued by an Additional Secretary. Both Election Commissioners wrote to the Cabinet Secretary the next day, and following a joint direction on July 30, that order was not put into effect. The commission also said Form 6 remains unchanged, can only be altered by the government, and that the SIR declaration is distinct from it.