Skip to content

Diwali Firecracker Curbs: Supreme Court Seeks Stronger Enforcement

By News Analysis India · · 4 min read

Diwali firecracker curbs in Delhi-NCR came under intense scrutiny at the Supreme Court on Thursday, which reserved its judgment after concluding arguments in the matter. The bench of Justice MM Sundaresh and Justice Prasanna B Varale pressed the Centre, the Delhi government, the Commission for Air Quality Management and other stakeholders on their pollution control efforts.

During the proceedings, the bench made a notable suggestion: well-known figures such as cricketer Virat Kohli could help spread awareness among the public.

The court made it clear that annual orders alone would not solve the air pollution crisis. A high-level, long-term and effective strategy is needed, it observed.

The bench said that every year it issues orders, which has effectively turned into an academic exercise. Compliance is weak and violations are widespread, so a new and innovative approach must be adopted.

Awareness among the younger generation was a special focus. The court asked why the government could not take the help of popular players like Virat Kohli or respected personalities to motivate people.

The bench observed that young people today are informed and inquisitive. If children are given accurate information, they may motivate their parents to avoid bursting firecrackers.

Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati, appearing for the Delhi government and CAQM, told the court that authorities were fully prepared. A new action plan will be enforced from November 1, she said. Only BS-6 vehicles will be allowed to enter Delhi from outside. Government office timings have been revised to reduce traffic congestion, and anti-smog guns have been placed at construction sites. Pollution control centres and the Vayu Rakshak initiative have been launched, and 608 anti-smog guns have been deployed across the capital.

The ASG also accepted that AQI readings were comparatively higher on the days when firecrackers had been allowed.

The court questioned the Delhi government on why only nine out of 39 monitoring stations were operational. It noted that there was no detailed compliance report on steps taken after earlier orders. Judges asked whether inspection teams had been constituted, how many sites were visited, whether any data was collected, and whether such data had been placed before the court.

The bench warned that passing orders would be meaningless unless they were enforced on the ground, otherwise the process would become a mockery.

The government was also directed to determine whether Chinese firecrackers were being sold in the market and to report what action had been taken. The court pointed out that traders aim to maximise profits, so monitoring and enforcement must be stringent.

The court acknowledged the emotions of people who want to celebrate festivals with fireworks. Festivals, it said, uplift spirits and bring positivity. The bench said it was not in favour of a complete ban because of its far-reaching consequences. Still, it told the government unambiguously that strict monitoring at the grassroots level must be ensured during festivals.

The court-appointed amicus curiae said firecrackers emit large quantities of particulate matter, and the chemicals and metals in them generate toxic gases when burnt. PM2.5 particles are extremely small, can reach the lungs, enter the blood and affect the body and brain.

Quoting specialist doctors in Delhi, the amicus said the lungs of non-smokers used to look pink, but black spots are now being seen even in the lungs of non-smoking adolescents. He added that in the 1980s nearly 90 per cent of lung cancer patients were smokers, while now about half have never smoked.

The amicus also told the court that the sale and verification system for so-called green firecrackers raises serious concerns. Ordinary crackers are being sold with green labels, many products do not carry QR codes, and several QR codes in use have been found to be fake. Even if green crackers are permitted, there is no effective mechanism to ensure only those are sold.

Green crackers are not entirely pollution-free, he said. Standards set by CSIR and NEERI indicate they produce about 30 per cent less emissions than normal crackers, yet still generate significant pollution. He noted that AQI rose sharply after Dussehra. In a region like Delhi-NCR, where air is already poor, extra pollution is a serious public health hazard. When air quality reaches severe levels, GRAP is invoked, construction is stopped and schools are sometimes moved online.

He asked how bursting crackers could be allowed at such a time when even essential activities are being restricted.

Petitioner Gopal Sankaranarayanan argued that the government was seeking two weeks to deliberate on policy, while firecracker sales and supply continued. If regulation is necessary, he said, immediate and effective steps must be taken.

Having heard all sides, the Supreme Court reserved its verdict. The final decision will determine the course of firecracker use and pollution control in Delhi-NCR during Diwali.