Skip to content

Is CPI(M) Ignoring Its Own Collective Rules? Insights from MA Baby’s Football Analogy

By News Analysis India · · 1 min read

In a high‑profile Central Committee session held in New Delhi, CPI(M) chief M.A. Baby turned to football to illustrate a growing concern within the party. He noted that the sport is celebrated for its emphasis on teamwork, discipline and adherence to a common set of rules – elements that mirror the ideals of a communist organization. Baby, an avid follower of the game who once watched Lionel Messi play in Kolkata, argued that political victories cannot be achieved by a single star performer; they require the confidence and joint effort of the entire squad. This comment coincided with a candid discussion among senior cadres about whether the party’s decision‑making has become overly centralized, especially after recent electoral defeats blamed on a top‑down leadership approach. Critics inside the party have highlighted a lack of dialogue with grassroots activists and an inclination to favor a few senior figures. By recalling the phrase “bend it like Beckham,” Baby suggested that true excellence comes from mastering the game while respecting its boundaries, raising an uncomfortable question: is the CPI(M) now willing to flex its own statutes for the benefit of a select few? The answer will likely determine whether the organization can revive its historic commitment to collective leadership.