CPI(M) Faces Internal Debate Over Mamata Ties
Tensions are rising among Left cadres following the release of a candid photograph from the India bloc rally held in New Delhi on Sunday. The picture shows CPI(M) chief M.A. Baby conversing closely with Mamata Banerjee, who smiles as he whispers in her ear. Given their contentious political history, the image has sparked anxiety across West Bengal’s traditional Left strongholds.
Until recently, the idea of a friendly rapport between Baby and the TMC chief was inconceivable. Mamata’s entire political trajectory was built on breaking the Left’s long-standing grip on West Bengal, a feat she accomplished in 2011, nearly 13 years after exiting the Congress fold. The sudden visibility of their camaraderie has forced the CPI(M) to confront uncomfortable questions about its future electoral strategy.
Party strategists are now divided over a critical question: Can the Left fight the BJP aggressively while maintaining an uncompromising stance against Mamata’s party in Bengal? Those advocating for closer ties argue that tactical alliances with rival regional parties are essential to defeat the BJP. They reference the CPI(M)’s past decision to support the Congress against what it called communal elements, noting that the party’s erosion of its core support base began after it pulled out of the UPA coalition.
Opponents of this strategy raise valid counterpoints. They highlight that the Left failed to unseat Mamata even when she was at her political peak and allied with Congress. Furthermore, the Left’s direct electoral clashes with the Congress in Kerala make any apparent thaw with Mamata politically awkward. Some insiders argue that Baby’s current outreach signals a strategic pivot away from the doctrine once articulated by veteran leader Prakash Karat.
The traditional Left position has always been that the BJP and TMC represent identical political threats. Party veterans have long warned that befriending Mamata would compromise the CPI(M)’s ideological independence, alienate its grassroots workers, and ignore documented grievances regarding the treatment of Left activists under Mamata’s administration.
Yet, the political landscape has undeniably shifted. Since Baby took charge, he has prioritized building a robust anti-BJP front. His discussions with Mamata inside the India bloc framework have been notably warm. With the CPI(M) holding far fewer seats in Parliament than in previous decades and the BJP dominating the national arena, many party members insist that opposition unity is now a survival necessity. Despite this, a vocal segment of the party remains deeply concerned that the visible closeness might signal a dangerous compromise on core principles.