Court Ruling Removes Rule 3A, Gives Relief to Quarry Operators
In a decisive order issued on 17 November, the Madras High Court held that Rule 3A of the Tamil Nadu Illegal Mining, Transportation and Mineral Storage and Mineral Dealer Rules, 2011, is unconstitutional. The division bench, led by Chief Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari and Justice G. Arul Murugan, concluded that the rule intruded upon the jurisdiction of the central Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957.
The rule had empowered the State Director of Geology and Mining to halt the movement of ballast, crushed stone, manufactured sand, metal jelly, gravel and other construction inputs outside Tamil Nadu’s borders. After a July amendment, a notification on 27 July imposed a three‑month embargo on such materials, later extended on 27 October for an additional three months, except for the Union Territories of Puducherry and Karaikal.
Multiple petitions – filed by mining lease holders, crusher owners, trade associations and private operators – contested the amendment’s legitimacy and the subsequent orders. They maintained that the restriction breached Article 301’s guarantee of free trade, and was inconsistent with Article 304(b) provisions that allow only limited state regulation of commerce.
The court’s verdict eliminates the ban, restoring the ability of quarry and crushing units to transport raw stone and aggregates to neighbouring states. Industry participants have welcomed the ruling as a major reprieve that safeguards their commercial interests and supports regional construction activities.