Court rebukes FDA for keeping dairy shop licence suspended despite 98% compliance
In a decisive ruling on August 18, the Bombay High Court scolded the Maharashtra Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for maintaining the suspension of Gurunank Dairy & Sweets' licence even after the retailer achieved a 98 percent compliance rating.
Acting Chief Justice Ravindra Ghugre and Justice Gautam Akhand cancelled the June 12 suspension order with immediate effect, allowing the Pune‑based sweet shop to reopen its retail outlet at Wadgeon Sheri.
The retailer had filed a petition after the FDA’s action caused an estimated loss of Rs 8.74 lakh. The court found the regulator’s policy “peculiar and defective,” noting that the compliance inspection on July 13 demonstrated the shop’s adherence to almost all food‑safety norms.
Despite the favourable inspection report, the FDA failed to lift the suspension, and the business remained closed. The judges highlighted that once a compliance level of 98 percent is documented, the licence should be reinstated without delay.
The High Court ordered the FDA to release a compensation package of Rs 5 lakh to the petitioner within a month. It also directed the agency to deposit the amount in the court’s registry, giving the shop owner free access to the funds.
The judgment underscores the judiciary’s stance that regulatory authorities must act proportionately and avoid unnecessary hardship on merchants, especially when compliance is demonstrably high.