Court Raps Unilateral Search Warrant in J&K Custody Case
The Jammu and Kashmir High Court has taken a stern view of a Srinagar family court that ordered police to retrieve a five‑year‑old child for her father.
Justice Rahul Bharati, delivering the opinion, said the lower court displayed both legal gaps and insensitivity by authorising a search warrant and directing law enforcement to fetch the daughter.
The matter arose after a petition filed under Article 227 by Shadab Hussain Mir contested the family court’s June 29, 2026 directive to the Chanapora SHO to locate the child and hand her over to the mother.
A prior divorce settlement dated January 25, 2025 gave the mother custody, but stipulated that the child would revert to the father if the mother remarried. Following the mother’s remarriage, the father took the child under his care.
The High Court observed that the father’s actions were consistent with the agreement and could not be automatically labeled illegal.
Justice Bharati faulted the family court for issuing a one‑sided search warrant without hearing the father or completing a thorough fact‑finding process, branding it as judicial insensitivity.
He also recommended that, should the child’s return have been essential, the court should have used a women’s police cell or other child‑sensitive mechanisms instead of sending ordinary police to the father’s home.
Lastly, the judgment queried the statutory authority of family courts under the Family Courts Act, 1984 to invoke Section 100 of the Indian Penal Code, a power the court affirmed belongs to district or sessions judges, not family courts.