Former IIT Student Questions Reservation Benefits After 98.5% Scores
Milind Chandwani, an alumnus of both IIT and IIM, posted a short video that has quickly spread across Indian social channels. He narrates an incident from his college days in 2013: a peer challenged him by asking why a 98.5 percent score seemed to matter when the peer secured admission offers from IIM with a modest 58 percent.
Both students hailed from middle‑class households. Chandwani’s friend did not rely on the reservation system, yet the quota helped him obtain a coveted seat, while Chandwani’s merit‑based application received no calls. This disparity left Chandwani questioning the equity of the reservation framework.
His outlook transformed after he started teaching under the “Teach For India” programme. Working with children from government schools, Chandwani realized that many who truly need reservation lack awareness of how to access it, rendering the system ineffective for its most vulnerable beneficiaries.
He clarifies that he does not claim every beneficiary of reservation is undeserving. Some genuinely require the support, and he does not label himself strictly for or against caste‑based quotas. However, he insists that any future removal of reservation must be preceded by a universal guarantee of quality education and equal opportunity for all low‑income students.
The clip appears amid a surge of online campaigns demanding the abolition or overhaul of reservation policies. While some sections of the public advocate for restructuring, others argue that such measures remain vital until broader socioeconomic inequities are eliminated.