Skip to content

Kabirdham Teacher Recruitment Case: Chargesheet Names 22 Accused

By News Analysis India · · 2 min read

A teacher recruitment case from nearly three decades ago has reached a critical stage in Chhattisgarh's Kabirdham district. The Anti-Corruption Bureau has submitted a chargesheet running to around 1,000 pages before the Special Court in Kawardha, concerning the 320 Shikshakarmi Varg-3 posts filled in Pandariya Janpad Panchayat.

A total of 22 people have been made accused. They include six former public servants and 16 candidates who were selected in the recruitment.

The investigation has raised concerns about several stages of the process, including the interview list, the marks awarded, the reservation arrangements and the role of selection committee members. The court will now take up hearings on these matters.

How the Case Began

The recruitment examination for the Shikshakarmi posts was conducted on December 25, 1998. Arjun Tiwari, who was then president of the Janpad Panchayat, filed a complaint regarding the selection. The complaint alleged tampering with the interview register, the award of teaching experience marks to students who were still regular college students, violations of reservation norms and benefits to relatives of committee members.

Based on the complaint, Crime No. 48/2000 was registered in 2000. The bureau has now presented its chargesheet, supported by oral and documentary evidence gathered during the investigation.

Irregularities in the Merit Order

According to the recruitment rules, merit lists were to be drawn separately for Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribe, Other Backward Class and General categories. Candidates equal to three times the number of vacancies in each category were to be called for interviews in order of merit.

The probe says teaching experience bonus marks were added to academic scores while the interview list was being prepared. This allegedly changed the order of merit. Some eligible candidates were left out of the interview process, while others who did not meet the merit criteria were included.

Divyang Quota and Reservation Concerns

The recruitment process has also been questioned over women's reservation, the selection of divyang candidates and the adjustment of different categories. Records cited in the investigation show that for four Scheduled Caste divyang posts, 12 candidates should have been called. Instead, only 10 of the 15 eligible candidates were called for interviews.

Allegations Against Committee Members

The investigation has found that relatives of then chairman Shankarlal Chandravanshi and members Brijbihari Vaishnav and Ambikadutt Sharma were among the applicants. It is alleged that the members attended the interviews of their relatives and gave them marks. It is also alleged that the relationships were not disclosed before the interviews.

The court will decide whether these allegations stand. If they are proven, the case will raise serious questions about the fairness of the selection committee.

Accused and Applicable Sections

The chargesheet names former CEO M.L. Bharti, Ambika Prasad Shandilya, former Block Education Officer N.L. Vastrakar, former Deputy Director of Public Instruction N.R. Verma, Shankarlal Chandravanshi and Hariram Ghritlahare, along with 16 selected candidates.

The bureau has said that three other accused, former CEO M.L. Badhai and members Brijbihari Vaishnav and Ambikadutt Sharma, have died.

Prosecution has been sought under Section 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, and under Sections 120B, 420, 467, 468 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code. The case will now proceed in court.