Four Pages Missing From CGPSC Answer Sheet, HC Awards Rs 50,000
A candidate who appeared for the Chhattisgarh Public Service Commission's State Service Mains examination has been awarded Rs 50,000 in compensation by the Bilaspur High Court after four pages of his answer sheet were found missing.
The pages were meant to hold answers to questions 9 to 12 of the General Studies Paper-5, carrying a combined total of 30 marks.
How the problem surfaced
Narayan Dutt, a resident of Bilaspur, had applied for the CGPSC state service examination based on an advertisement issued in 2018. He cleared the preliminary examination and appeared for the mains, but was not finally selected. Later, he sought a copy of his answer sheet through an RTI application and discovered that pages 17 to 20 were absent.
Evidence during evaluation
The court heard that signs of pages being removed were present in the answer sheet and that the discrepancy had been identified during evaluation. Still, the candidate was not told about it on time. An inquiry launched to find the person responsible was also not completed.
The Commission's argument
The Commission told the court that the last selected unreserved candidate had secured 737.5 marks, whereas the petitioner had 695.5. It maintained that even if the missing 30 marks were restored, the petitioner would still fall short. The Commission further pointed out that the candidate had signed a satisfaction certificate after reviewing his answer sheet.
The High Court's reasoning
The bench found that even with the maximum 30 additional marks, the candidate would not have qualified for the interview on merit. As a result, the court did not accept the claim that he should be called for the interview.
At the same time, the court held that the lapse itself could not be overlooked. Selection and accountability were treated as separate issues, and the failure to act on the evaluation-stage discovery was held to be a serious shortcoming.
Compensation ordered
The examiner and the concerned officer have been directed to pay Rs 50,000 to the candidate within three months. The petition has been disposed of with these directions.
Experts see the ruling as a reminder that answer sheet integrity, transparent evaluation, and timely fixing of responsibility are essential for trust in public recruitment examinations.