Legal Precedent and Supreme Court Rulings Shape Tata Trusts' Stance
The Trusts pointed out that Tata Sons cannot ignore the AOA after the Supreme Court’s earlier judgment in the Cyrus Mistry dispute. In that case, Articles 104B and 121 concerning "affirmative voting rights" of trust‑nominated directors were deemed a lawful safeguard for a majority shareholder, not a repressive tool. The apex court upheld the protective clause, stating the company could not backtrack on a constitutional right it had successfully defended in court. Tata Trusts therefore argue that the same principle applies to the current chairman re‑appointment, where the affirmative voting right of their directors was not exercised in line with the AOA.